Search Fund vs. Private Equity vs. Strategic Buyer
When owners start thinking about selling, they usually hear from two kinds of buyers: private equity funds and strategic buyers. There’s a third path most owners haven’t heard of. Here’s how all three compare, plainly.
The three buyers
Private equity fund
A fund raises money from investors and buys several companies. It usually holds each one for a set period, then sells it to the next buyer. A portfolio manager oversees the investment and a hired CEO often runs the company day to day.
Strategic buyer
A larger company in your industry buys yours to add to what it already does. Your business gets folded into theirs.
Search fund
A search fund is one person, backed by investors, who sets out to buy one company and run it as CEO. That’s Castle Pines. I’m buying one company and leading it myself, full time, for the long term.
Side by side
| Topic | Castle Pines | Private equity fund | Strategic buyer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who runs it after closing | John, as full-time CEO | A portfolio manager, plus a hired CEO | The buyer’s management team |
| Time horizon | Long term, with no set exit | Usually a 3-to-7-year hold, then resold | Absorbed for good |
| Your company’s name | Stays | Often stays, until the next sale | Often retired or merged |
| Your people | The team that built it stays and grows | Cost cuts are common | Overlapping roles are often cut |
| Your role | Flexible. As involved as you want | Often required to stay | Usually limited |
| Who you deal with | The decision-maker, directly | Associates and an investment committee | Corporate development and lawyers |
| What they optimize for | Growth and the long-term health of one company | Return on the fund | Fit with their existing business |
What changes for you
Who leads after you
With a fund, the person who buys your company usually isn’t the person who runs it. With a strategic buyer, their team takes over. With Castle Pines, the person you meet on the first call is the person who runs the company.
How long they plan to stay
A fund has a clock. It needs to sell your company to return money to its investors. I don’t have a set exit. I’m here to build one company for the long term.
Your people and your name
Strategic buyers often cut overlapping roles and retire the name. Funds often cut costs to hit their return. I want to keep the team that built the business, invest in them and keep the name customers already trust.
Your role after closing
Some buyers need you to stay for years. Some want you gone on day one. I’m flexible. Stay a year, a few months or not at all. It’s your call.
To be fair
Private equity and strategic buyers can be the right answer for some owners. A strategic buyer may pay for the fit with its business. A fund may bring a bigger platform. The question is what matters most to you: the price alone, or the price plus what happens to your company, your people and your name after you step away.
Common questions
Is a search fund well funded?
Yes. Castle Pines is backed by 14 investors, including Peterson Partners. The capital is committed to buying and growing one company.
Do I have to stay after the sale?
No. Your role is flexible. Stay as involved as you want, for as long as you want, or hand over the keys at closing.
Will my employees keep their jobs?
The plan is to keep the team that built the business and help them grow. Your people are why it works.
Who will I be dealing with?
Me, directly. You’ll talk to the decision-maker from the first call to closing.
How does the process work?
Six steps: a first conversation, a valuation and fit check, an onsite visit, agreeing on terms, confirming the details and handing over the keys. You always know what comes next.
Talk with the buyer, not a committee.
Thirty minutes, confidential, no obligation.
